They had one amazing night and he felt that they were a perfect match. She, on the other hand, saw them more as friends. Plus, she met Ethan Robbie Amell the next day and it turns out destiny had much more in store for them than it did for her and Noah.
Common Sense says
Watch the video. Title: When We First Met Three friends are on the verge of getting their video game financed when their benefactor is taken hostage by terrorists. A high school senior instigates a social pecking order revolution after finding out that she has been labeled the DUFF - Designated Ugly Fat Friend - by her prettier, more popular counterparts. Two friends on a road trip compete for the affections of a handsome man when their flight is redirected due to a hurricane. A young woman disenchanted with love mysteriously finds herself trapped inside a romantic comedy. Everyone assumed Sasha and Marcus would wind up together except for Sasha and Marcus.
Unrequited love is something most people have experienced at some point of time in their lives. Secondly, the term trivialises friendship. Screenshot from YouTube video. But the night ends with Noah finding out that Avery is interested in friendship instead of a romantic relationship. Three years later, on the day Avery is getting engaged to someone else, Noah discovers a way to travel back through time to the day he first met Avery. This Groundhog Day -esque premise had a lot of potential for both romance and comedy, mainly because Noah never blames Avery for not being interested in him and instead focuses on self-improvement and changing himself every time he gets an opportunity to travel back through time. When We First Met also ultimately gives the right message about friendship.